judyrecords
search tips
740 million+
United States Court Cases

Wyoming Supreme/Appellate Court Record

DAVID FISHER and MARY BREZIK-FISHER v. WYOMING DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY and BROOK MINING COMPANY, LLC

Case Heading (S-20-0017)
Case Number:S-20-0017Case Docketed On:01/21/2020
Linked To: S-20-0016
Status:Closed
Original Court:First Judicial District Laramie CountyCase Type:Direct Appeal - Civil - City, County, State and Local Powers (Title 16)
Short Title:DAVID FISHER and MARY BREZIK-FISHER v. WYOMING DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY and BROOK MINING COMPANY, LLC
Full Title:DAVID FISHER and MARY BREZIK-FISHER, Appellants (Petitioners), v. WYOMING DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY and BROOK MINING COMPANY, LLC, Appellees (Respondents).

- Party Information
RoleParty NameAttorney(s)
AppellantDavid FisherJay A. Gilbertz
AppellantMary Brezik FisherJay A. Gilbertz
AppelleeDepartment of Environmental QualityBridget L. Hill
James Kaste
Matthew Taylor VanWormer
AppelleeBrook Mining Co., LLCPatrick Reed Day
JoAnna Sue DeWald
Thomas L. Sansonetti

- Case Decision Information
Issues:Administrative Law and Procedure, Natural Resources - Mining and Minerals
Opinion Number:2020 WY 127
Citation:

Docketing Filter View
Display:

Docket Information
Filing DateDocument DescriptionDocket Entry TypeDocket Entry SubtypeStatus
01/21/2020Event - Docketed and indexedEventDocketed and indexedFinal
01/21/2020Notice-Incoming - Record completion notice from district courtNotice-IncomingRecord completion notice from district courtFinal
01/21/2020Fees - Docket fee receivedFeesDocket fee receivedFinal
01/21/2020Notice-Outgoing - Docketing letterNotice-OutgoingDocketing letterFinal
01/21/2020Notice-Internal - Recusal memo from Justice BoomgaardenNotice-InternalRecusal memoFinal
01/24/2020Notice-Outgoing - Other - Amended Case CaptionNotice-OutgoingOtherFinal
03/03/2020Brief - AppellantsBriefAppellantFinal
03/05/2020Event - Hardcopy received - Brief of Appellants David Fisher and Mary Brezik-Fisher; and received copy of designation of record on appealEventHardcopy receivedFinal
04/03/2020Motion - ConsolidateMotionConsolidateFinal
04/06/2020Order - Consolidating cases (after briefing complete)OrderConsolidating casesFinal
04/23/2020Brief - Appellee (DEQ)BriefAppelleeFinal
04/24/2020Notice-Outgoing - Notice of case maturityNotice-OutgoingNotice of case maturityFinal
04/24/2020Brief - Appellee (Brook Mining)BriefAppelleeFinal
04/24/2020Notice-Incoming - Designation of record (DEQ)Notice-IncomingDesignation of recordFinal
04/29/2020Brook Mining Company, LLC's Motion to Strike or Reclassify Appellee Brief of DEQ (Opposed)MotionStrikeFinal
04/29/2020Brook Mining Company, LLCs Motion to Clarify Allotment of Oral Argument Time (Exclude DEQ from Appellee's OA time; Stipulated only if DEQ given opportunity to present OA)MotionClarificationFinal
05/07/2020Brief - Appellant reply (David Fischer and Mary Brezik-Fisher)BriefAppellant replyFinal
05/07/2020Appellant Fishers' Motion to Correct the RecordMotionCorrect recordFinal
05/08/2020Notice-Outgoing - Request for transmitted record on appealNotice-OutgoingRequest for transmitted record on appealFinal
05/12/2020Order - Assignment of judge/justice - District Judge John R. Perry assigned to act in this matter for Justice Lynne J. Boomgaarden who is recusedOrderAssignment of judge/justiceFinal
05/12/2020Wyoming Department of Environmental Quality's Response to Motion to Strike or Reclassify Appellee BriefResponse/ObjectionMotionFinal
05/12/2020Response to Brook's Motion to "Reclassify" by Appellants David Fisher and Mary Brezik-FisherResponse/ObjectionMotionFinal
05/14/2020Order - Oral argument scheduledOrderOral argument scheduledFinal
05/14/2020Powder River Basin Resource Council's Response to Brook Mining Company, LLC's Motion to Strike or Reclassify Appellee Brief of DEQResponse/ObjectionMotionFinal
05/14/2020Notice-Internal - Recusal memo from Justice GrayNotice-InternalRecusal memoFinal
05/19/2020Notice-Internal - Recusal memo, Chief Justice DavisNotice-InternalRecusal memoFinal
05/20/2020Order - Assignment of judge/justice - District Judge Richard L. Lavery assigned to act in this matter for Justice Gray, who is recusedOrderAssignment of judge/justiceFinal
05/20/2020Order - Assignment of judge/justice - District Judge Timothy C. Day assigned to act in this matter for Chief Justice Davis, who is recusedOrderAssignment of judge/justiceFinal
05/21/2020Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting received by Matt VanWormer obo appellee (DEQ)Notice-IncomingReceipt acknowledgment - oral argument settingFinal
05/21/2020Record - Transmitted record on appeal from district court clerk, ten volumes. DC Volumes 1 thru 3 - Original papers; DC Volume 4 - Transcript; DC Volume 5 - Agency Record: DEQ volumes #1-6 and 8-16 (15 spiral bound volumes); DC Volume 6 - Agency Record (DEQ vol. #7 which contains 10 transcripts; DEQ vols. #17-22: DEQ exhibits 1-6); DC Volume 7 - Agency Record (DEQ vols. #23-27: DEQ exhibits 7-11); DC Volume 8 - Agency Record (DEQ vols. #28-31: DEQ exhibits 12-26); DC Volume 9 - Agency Record (DEQ exhibit 32 in mail tube); DC Volume 10 - Agency Record (6 vols.)RecordTransmitted record on appealFinal
05/21/2020Notice-Outgoing - Transmitted record on appeal filedNotice-OutgoingTransmitted record on appeal filedFinal
05/22/2020Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting from Jay A. Gilbertz obo Appellants (Fishers)Notice-IncomingReceipt acknowledgment - oral argument settingFinal
05/27/2020Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting received by Shannon Anderson obo Powder RiverNotice-IncomingReceipt acknowledgment - oral argument settingFinal
05/27/2020Order on Motion to Strike or Reclassify Appellee Brief of DEQ, Order Granting Motion to Clarify Allotment of Oral Argument Time, and Order Granting Motion to Correct RecordOrderOtherFinal
06/17/2020Notice-Internal - Oral argument notice - argued before Justices Fox and Kautz, Judges Day, Perry and Lavery (Jay A. Gilbertz o/b/o Fishers; Shannon R. Anderson o/b/o Powder River Basin Resource Council; James Kaste, Matthew VanWormer argument by Mr.VanWormer o/b/o DEQ; Patrick Day o/b/o Brook Mining Company) and taken under advisement.Notice-InternalOral argument noticeFinal
06/26/2020Service - Certified mail signature return card - record sent by Clerk's office to law clerk - Box 1 of 2 rcvd., 6/22 and Box 2 of 2 rcvd 6/23.ServiceCertified mail signature return cardFinal
07/07/2020(DEQ's) Notice of Subsequent Event Pertinent to MootnessNotice-IncomingStatus report - otherFinal
08/05/2020Powder River Basin Resource Council's Notice of Related Administrative AppealNotice-IncomingStatus report - otherFinal
09/28/2020Opinion - Opinion and journal order, dismissing case as issues are moot with District Judge Day writing for the Court.OpinionOpinion and journal orderFinal
10/14/2020Notice-Outgoing - MandateNotice-OutgoingMandateFinal
10/14/2020Record - Record returned to district courtRecordRecord returned to district courtFinal
10/14/2020Notice-Outgoing - Record return letterNotice-OutgoingRecord return letterFinal
10/14/2020Event - Case closedEventCase closedFinal