judyrecords
search tips
740 million+
United States Court Cases

District Of Columbia Court Of Appeals Record

EUGENE BEARD V. GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER

Case Information: 86-CV-1327
Short Caption:EUGENE BEARD V. GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBERClassification:Appeals - Civil - Other Civil
Lead:86-CV-1327Consolidated: 86-CV-1328 , 86-CV-1331
Superior Court or Agency Case Number:CA1694-86Filed Date:09/15/1986

Opening Event Date:09/15/1986Case Status:Closed
Record Completed:07/06/1987Post-Decision Matter Pending:
Briefs Completed:06/28/1990
Argued/Submitted:10/25/1990
Disposition:Next Scheduled Action:
Mandate Issued:04/05/1991

Party Information
Appellate RoleParty NameIFPAttorney(s)Arguing AttorneyE-Filer
AppellantJohn Doe N
Philip Clarke Baten YN
AppelleeJohn Doe N
L. Palmer ForetNN
AppelleeJohn Doe N
Carmen M. Shepard NN
AppelleeJohn Doe N
William G. Mcmurtrie NN
AppelleeJohn Doe N
Steven N. Muchnick NN
AppelleeJohn Doe N
Sheldon Feldman NN
AppelleeJohn Doe N
Robert I. Chaskes NN
AppelleeJohn Doe N
Joseph W. Gelb NN
AppelleeJohn Doe N
Kevin M. MurphyYY
AppelleeJohn Doe N
William J. CarterNN
AppelleeJohn Doe N
Peter K. Tompa YN
AppelleeJohn Doe N

Events
Event DateStatusDescriptionResult
01/01/1901BEARD, EUGENE ET AL GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY, ET AL
01/01/1903NOTE - 01 CON 86-1328 THRU 86-1331 NOTE - 01 CON 87-1457 NOTE - 02 111486 ORDER: SS, VACATING NOTE - 02 11/4 OTSC; APLT DIR TO TAKE NOTE - 03 NEC STEPS TO CAUSE REC TO BE NOTE - 03 PREPARED & TRANSMITTED FORTH- NOTE - 04 WITH; APLT BR DUE 40 DAYS AFT NOTE - 04 REC IS FILED. NOTE - 05 052187 ORDER: CONS #87-464 W/# NOTE - 05 86-1327 THRU 86-1331; FO: W/IN NOTE - 06 10 DAYS ALL PARTIES TO THE CON NOTE - 06 APPEALS ARE TO FILE A SETTLEMT NOTE - 07 STATEMENT THAT SETS OUT THE NOTE - 07 FOLLOWING: (1) the issues re- NOTE - 08 maining in these appeals (2) NOTE - 08 the general areas of agreement NOTE - 09 in these appeals; & (3) a NOTE - 09 statement from each attny in- NOTE - 10 dicating that he/she has NOTE - 10 settlement authority from his/ NOTE - 11 her client. NOTE - 11 NOTE - 12 063087 ORDER: GRANT APLTS' MO NOTE - 12 TO W/DRAW FROM SETTLEMENT CONF NOTE - 13 FO: APLTS TO TAKE NEC STEPS TO NOTE - 13 CAUSE RECORD TO BE PREPARED & NOTE - 14 TRANSMITTED FORTHWITH; APLTS NOTE - 14 BR DUE 40 DAYS THEREAFTER. NOTE - 15 9/11/87 ORD: APLE'S, GOODYEAR NOTE - 15 & RALEIGH TO SHOW CAUSE IN 10 NOTE - 16 DAYS WHY APLT'S MO SHLD NOT BE NOTE - 16 GRANTED & COUNTER DR FL IN NOTE - 17 87-464 BE STRIKEN. NOTE - 17 NOTE - 18 011488 ORD: GRANT MO TO STRIKE NOTE - 18 IN PART W/O PREJUDICE TO APLES NOTE - 19 MOVING TO SUPP THE RECORD W/A NOTE - 19 SHOWING OF PREJUDICE OR NOTE - 20 NECESSITY; GRANT MO TO W/DRAW NOTE - 20 & W/DRAW APPEARANCE OF NOTE - 21 MARGARET K. PFEIFFER AS COUNSL NOTE - 21 FOR ALLIED STORES CORP & ENTER NOTE - 22 APPEARANCE OF ROBERT I. NOTE - 22 CHASKES. NOTE - 23 3/7/88 ORD: SS, CONS 87-1457 NOTE - 23 W/86-1327-86-1331 & 87-464; NOTE - 24 87-1457 REMOVED FROM 3/10/88 NOTE - 24 SETTLEMENT CONF CAL;APLTS TO NOTE - 25 TAKE STEPS TO HAVE COMPLETE NOTE - 25 REC FILED. NOTE - 26 12/22/89 ORD: BRIEFS OF APLTS- NOTE - 26 X-APLES (EUGENE BEARD), ET AL NOTE - 27 SHALL BE FILED W/IN 40 DAYS NOTE - 27 FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER, NOTE - 28 APLES BRIEFS DUE 30 DAYS NOTE - 28 THEREAFTER. NOTE - 29 4/16/90 ORD: GRNTG MOS OF NOTE - 29 BEARD TO EXT TM TO FILE BRF; NOTE - 30 DENYG MOS TO DISMISS; CLK TO NOTE - 30 FILE BRF OF APLT-X-APLE, BEARD NOTE - 31 ; BRFS OF APLES-X-APLTS DUE NOTE - 31 W/IN 30 DAYS. NOTE - 32 5/24/90 ORD: GRANTG MO OF NOTE - 32 APLES-X-APLTS TO FILE BRFS TO NOTE - 33 EXTENT BRFS DUE IN 30 DAYS; NOTE - 33 NFX; GRANTG MO OF EUGENE BEARD NOTE - 34 TO AMEND & ADD TO THE RECORD; NOTE - 34 CLK TO FILE ATTACHMENTS TO THE NOTE - 35 MO AS A SUPP RECORD. NOTE - 35 NOTE - 36 8/8/90 ORD: GRANTG MO OF NOTE - 36 GOODYEAR TIRE TO SUPP THE REC; NOTE - 37 CLK TO FILE ATTACHMENTS TO THE NOTE - 37 MO AS A SUPP REC; GRANTG MO OF NOTE - 38 EUGENE BEARD FOR EXT OF TIME NOTE - 38 TO FILE REPLY BRF IN 86-1327 NOTE - 39 THRU 86-1331 & 87-464 AND THE NOTE - 39 BRF OF APLE IN 87-1457 ON OR NOTE - 40 BEOFRE 8/27/90, NFX. NOTE - 40
01/01/1904JUDGE - PY AUTHOR - RECUSED - Y
01/01/1905TRDATE- 90/10/25 ACTION - ARG ATTY 1 - BATENP FOR - APPELLANTS ATTY 2 - TOMPAP FOR - APLE GOODYEAR ATTY 3 - SCANLONR FOR - APLE W&L
01/01/1906 FORETL VACATED 5/10/90 MCMURTRIEW J.C. PENNEY COMPANY MUCHNICKS VACATED (WAS FOR CITICORP) FELDMANS FOR: CITICORP RETAIL SERVICES CHASKESR ALLIED STORES CORP. GELBJ FOR CITICORP RETAIL SERVICES MURPHYK FOR: GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER CO CARTERW FOR: GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER CO TOMPAP FOR: GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER CO SCANLONR WOODWARD & LOTHROP
09/15/1986FiledOPENING EVENT - Opening Event
09/30/1986CIVIL APPEAL STATEMENT RJG PANEL SCDATE 093086 SCHPRD CAS
09/30/1986DESIGNATION OF RECORD RJG PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
09/30/1986$50.00 DOCKETING FEE PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/03/1986$5 PAID TO DC TREASURER VS PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/16/1986ORDER 86-1327 THRU 86-1331 CON;NO 7A APLTS TO FILE DR/SRT W/SUP CT & SERVE COPIES IN 10 DAYS. EBP PANELPY SCDATE 100986 SCHPRD CHECK
10/28/1986COUNTER DESIGNATION OF RECORD (WOODWARD & LOTHROP) GG PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
11/04/1986ORDER APLT IN 10 DAYS OTSC WHY CASE SHLD NOT BE DISMISSED. (NO DR & SRT) EBP PANELPY SCDATE 102786 SCHPRD DR
11/14/1986ORDER SEE NOTE FIELDS 02 - 04. EBP PANELPY SCDATE 111486 SCHPRD ANSA
11/25/1986APPELLEE'S MOTION TO DISMISS/WITHDRAW APPEAL APPEAL IN 86-1327, 86-1328 AND 86-1331 GG PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
12/08/1986APPELLANT MOTION TO EXTEND TIME TO FILE OPPOSITIONTO APLE'S MOTION TO DISMISS TO 1/12/87 IN 86-1327, 86-1328 & 86-1331 GG PANEL SCDATE 120886 SCHPRD OPA EXTDTE 011287
01/02/1987APPELLEE'S MOTION TO DISMISS/WITHDRAW APPEAL APPEAL IN 86-1330 JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
01/12/1987APPELLANT'S OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS GG PANEL SCDATE 011287 SCHPRD OPA
01/29/1987APPELLEE'S MOTION TO DISMISS/WITHDRAW APPEAL IN 86-1329 GG PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
02/20/1987ORDER DENYING MOTIONS TO DISMISS CWC PANELMKRO SCDATE 021187 SCHPRD VS
03/05/1987SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE BEFORE PY PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
05/05/1987RECEIVED NOTICE OF APPELLANT RE FILING OF NEW APPEAL (#87-464) MLH PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
05/21/1987ORDER SEE NOTE FIELDS 05 - 11. EBP PANELPY SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/01/1987STATEMENT OF APPELLEE (ALLIED STORES) IN RESPONSE TO MAY 21ST COURT ORDER JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/01/1987STATEMENT OF APPELLEE (RALEIGHS) RE: COURT'S 5/21/87 ORDER PB PANEL SCDATE 060187 SCHPRD STATE
06/02/1987STATEMENT OF APPELLEE (GOODYEAR) IN RESPOSNE TO MAY 21ST COURT ORDER JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/02/1987STATEMENT OF APPELLANT (BEARD & ELAM AVERS) IN RESPONSE TO MAY 21ST COURT ORDER JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/02/1987STATEMENT OF APPELLEE (GARFINCKLES, INC) IN RESPONSE TO MAY 21ST COURT ORDER JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/03/1987COUNTER DESIGNATION OF RECORD OF APPELLEE, GARFINCKELS, INC, ADOPTS CAS & CDR OF GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANY MLH PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/04/1987STATEMENT OF APPELLEE, J.C. PENNEY CO., RE 5/21/87 ORDER MLH PANEL SCDATE 060187 SCHPRD STATE
06/04/1987STATEMENT OF APLE (WOODWARD & LOTHROP, INC.) IN RESPONSE TO MAY 21ST COURT ORDER JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/09/1987STATEMENT OF APPELLEE (SAKS & COMPANY) IN RESPONSE TO MAY 21ST COURT ORDER JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/11/1987MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MOTION OF APPELLANT TO WITHDRAW FROM SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/24/1987APPEARANCE OF STEVEN MUCHNICK AS COUNSEL FOR APPELLEE PB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/24/1987STATEMENT OF APPELLEE (CITICORP RETAIL SERVICES) IN RESPONSE TO MAY 21ST COURT ORDER JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/30/1987ORDER SEE NOTE FIELDS 12 - 14. EBP PANELPY SCDATE 030587 SCHPRD SCNFD
06/30/1987RECORD ON APPEAL PB PANEL SCDATE 073087 SCHPRD R
07/06/1987FiledRecord Completed
07/08/1987RECEIVED APPELLEE'S COUNTER DESIGNATION OF RECORD IN 87-464 JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
07/13/1987COUNTER DESIGNATION OF RECORD OF APLE'S RALEIGH STORES CORP. IN 87-464 PB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
07/17/1987APPELLANT'S MOTION TO STRIKE APLE'S GOODYEAR & RALEIGH COUNTERDESIGNATION OF RECORD IN 87-464 PB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
09/11/1987ORDER SEE NOTE FIELDS 15-17. DAS PANELPY SCDATE 072987 SCHPRD CHECK
09/21/1987APPELLEE'S ANSWER/RESPONSE OF (RALEIGHS) TO SEPT 11TH COURT ORDER REGARDING COUNTER- DESIGNATION OF RECORD JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
09/29/1987APPELLANT'S OPPOSITION TO APPELLEE'S RESPONSE TO SEPTEMBER 11TH ORDER JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/02/1987RECEIVED APLE'S (GOODYEAR) SUPPLEMENT TO MOTION TO STRIKE & RESPONSE TO SEPTEMBER 11TH ORDER JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/07/1987APLE MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ANSWER/RESPONSE OF (GOODYEAR) TO COURT'S 9/11 ORDER & TO FILE SUPPLEMENT TO OPPOSITION PB PANEL SCDATE 100787 SCHPRD CHECK
10/14/1987APPEARANCE OF SHELDON FELDMAN (CITICORP RETAIL SERVICE, INC.) ON BEHALF OF APPELLEE JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
11/12/1987COUNSEL'S MOTION TO WITHDRAW FOR BUSINESS REASONS OF MARGARET A. PFEIFFER & SUB- STITUTE ROBERT I. CHASKES FOR APPELLEE IN 86-1331 JB PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
01/14/1988ORDER SEE NOTE FILEDS 18-22. ACG PANELFEST SCDATE 072087 SCHPRD CHECK
02/29/1988RECEIVED SETTLEMENT STATEMENT OF APPEL- LEE, J.C. PENNEY, INC. MLH PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
03/07/1988ORDER SEE NOTE FIELDS 23-25. DAS PANELPY SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
12/22/1989ORDER THIS COURT'S 12/1/89 ORDER IS HEREBY VACATED, F/O THAT THE (SEE NOTES 26 THRU 28) JB PANELRO SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
02/01/1990APLT-X-APLE MOTION TO EXTEND TIME TO FILE BRIEF TO 3/5/90 AJ PANEL SCDATE 013190 SCHPRD BAE
02/13/1990APPELLEE'S MOTION TO DISMISS/WITHDRAW APPEAL AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
02/13/1990APPELLEE'S OPPOSITION TO APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR AN EXT. OF TIME TO FILE BRIEF RJG PANEL SCDATE 021390 SCHPRD OPEA
02/23/1990APPELLEE'S MOTION TO DISMISS/WITHDRAW APPEAL 86-1326 THRU 86-1331 & 87-464 JT PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
02/26/1990APPELLANT'S OPPOSITION IN 86-1327 THRU 86-1331 & 87-464 MO FOR ADDITIONAL TIME TO FI BR AND TO MO TO DIS. AJ PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
03/05/1990APPELLANT'S OPPOSITION TO MO TO DISMISS IN 86-1327 THRU 86-1331 & 87-464 AJ PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
04/02/1990RECEIVED APLT X APLE BRIEF AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
04/16/1990APPELLANT/CROSS-APPELLEE'S BRIEF (EUGENE BEARD) CWC PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
04/16/1990ORDER SEE NOTE FIELDS 29-31 CWC PANELRO SCDATE 030890 SCHPRD CHECK
04/17/1990MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MOTION OF APLT/X/APLE TO AMEND AND ADD TO THE RECORD AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
04/30/1990APLE-X-APLT MOTION TO EXTEND TIME TO FILE BRIEF TO 7-16-90 AD PANEL SCDATE 050790 SCHPRD BEA
05/10/1990APPEARANCE OF KEVIN M. MURPHY, WILLIAM CARTER & PETER J. TOMPA ON BEHALF OF APPELLEE RJG PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
05/24/1990ORDER SEE NOTE FIELDS 32-35 CWC PANELRO SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
05/24/1990SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD (ATTACHMENTS TO EUGENE BEARD'S 4/17/90 MOTION). CWC PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/25/1990APPELEE'S BRIEF (GOODYEAR) AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/25/1990APPELLEE/CROSS-APPELLANT'S BRIEF (FOR 87-464 ONLY) AJ PANEL SCDATE 062590 SCHPRD BEA
06/28/1990FiledBriefing Completed
06/28/1990APPEARANCE OF ROBERT SCANLON FOR WOODWARD & LOTHROP AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
06/28/1990APPELEE'S BRIEF OF WOODWARD & LOTHROP AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
07/06/1990APLE MOTION FOR LEAVE TO SUPPLEMENT THE RECORD AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
07/09/1990APLT MOTION TO EXTEND TIME TO FILE REPLY BRIEF OF APPELLANT FOR BOTH BRIEFS TO AUGUST 27, 1990 RJG PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
08/08/1990ORDER SEE NOTE FIELDS 36-40. CWC PANELRO SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
08/08/1990SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD (ATTACHMENTS TO 7/6/90 MO TO SUPP THE REC FILED BY GOODYEAR TIRE) CWC PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
08/27/1990APPELLANT'S REPLY OF EUGENE BEARD AJ PANEL SCDATE 082790 SCHPRD RBA
08/28/1990MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MOTION OF BEARD T0 FILE COMBINED BRIEF AND REPLY BRIEF AJ PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
09/14/1990ORDER GRANT APLT/APLE BEARD'S MO TO FL COMBINED BRF. MEH PANELFF SCDATE 090590 SCHPRD VS
09/14/1990APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF OF GOODYEAR IN 87-1457 AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
09/14/1990APPELLEE'S REPLY TO BEARD'S MOTION TO FILE COMBINED BRIEF AJ PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/12/1990MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MOTION OF APLE (WOODIES) FOR LEAVE TO ALLOW MORE THAN TWO COUNSEL TO BE HEARD AT ORAL ARGUMENT AJ PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/19/1990MEMORANDUM ADVISED BY COUNSEL THAT 10/12 MOTION RE ARGUMENT IS MOOT. MEH PANELRBH SCDATE 110590 SCHPRD OPA
10/22/1990APLE MOTION FOR LEAVE TO SUPPLEMENT THE RECORD AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/23/1990RECEIVED SUGGESTION OF BANKRUPTCY FROM GARFINKELS, INC. & ITS AFFIL- IATE GARFINKELS HOLDING CO RJG PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/24/1990ORDER COUNSEL TO ADVISE W/I 5 DAYS RE SPECIFIC QUESTIONS RE BANK- RUPTCY STATMENT. MEH PANELROBESC SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/25/1990FiledACTION - Argued / Submitted
10/25/1990ARGUED PANELRGBESC SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/25/1990ORDER GRANT MOT OF APLE/CROSS APLT TO SUPP REC WITH ATTACHMENTS TO MOTION OF 10/22. MEH PANELROBESC SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/25/1990SUPPLEMENTAL RECORD ATTACHMENTS TO 10/22/90 MOTION OF GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER CO. MEH PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/26/1990STATEMENT OF APLE PURSUANT TO CHIEF JUDGE'S REQUEST AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/29/1990MEMORANDUM TRANSMITTING GOODYEAR'S STATE- MENT DATED 10/26/90 TO DIV MEH PANELFF SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/29/1990MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MOTION OF GARFINKLE'S IN REPRESENTAT. AS TO CORPORATE ENTITIES AND STATUS AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/29/1990MISCELLANEOUS PROCEDURAL MOTION OF APPELLEE, GARFINKELS, BY DIRECTION OF COURT ORDER RJG PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/29/1990STATEMENT OF APPELLEE CITICORP PURSUANT TO JUDGES' REQUEST AT ORAL ARG. RJG PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
10/30/1990MEMORANDUM TRANSMITTING STATMENTS OF CITICORP & GARFINKLE'S TO DIV. MEH PANELFF SCDATE 110890 SCHPRD CHECK
11/01/1990STATEMENT OF APLE PURSUANT TO CHIEF JUDGE'S REQUEST AJ PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
11/02/1990STATEMENT OF APLE J.C. PENNY PURSUANT TO CHIEF JUDGE'S REQUEST AD PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
11/14/1990RECEIVED APLE AMENDED REPRESENTATION AS TO COPORATE ENTITIES AND STATUS AJ PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
02/26/1991AFFIRMED JUDGMENT AF JUDGMENT ON APPEAL PANELRGSCFA SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
02/26/1991DISP NO - 01 DISP - AF METH -OPN JUDGE -SW CITE 587 A.2d 195
02/26/1991OPINION TYPE M JUDGE - SW PAGE # - 0518
02/26/1991PROCEED WITH APPEAL, NO LONGER ON HOLD/STAYED
04/04/1991ORDER THAT THIS APPEAL IS SEVERED FROM NO. 87-464 FOR PURPOSE OF ISSUANCE OF THE MANDATE SL PANELRO SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
04/05/1991MANDATE ISSUED PANEL SCDATE 000000 SCHPRD
04/26/1991APPELLEE'S OPPOSITION (JOINT) TO BEARD'S PETITION FOR REHEARING EN BANC RJG PANEL SCDATE 042991 SCHPRD ANSE
03/06/1992CASE STAYED